SBA Loan Settlement: How an Offer in Compromise Works (2026)
A letter from the U.S. Treasury about your SBA loan is one of the most frightening pieces of mail a business owner can open. The balance has grown, there's a new collection fee on top of it, and the letter may come from a private collection agency you've never heard of. Our office is hearing from more Texas business owners every month who are in exactly this spot, many of them with COVID-era EIDL loans and some with 7(a) loans that went bad years ago.
Video transcript
Got a letter from the U.S. Treasury about your SBA loan? You're probably wondering: can it still be settled?
Sometimes, yes. Federal law allows an offer in compromise for less than the balance. But there's no standard discount, and no one is entitled to one.
Your path depends on four things: your loan program, who's collecting now, who signed, and what you need resolved.
Being sent to Treasury doesn't end settlement. Treasury can generally approve compromises up to five hundred thousand dollars in principal. Larger ones need the Justice Department.
If you personally guaranteed the loan, you're a separate party. Settling for one person doesn't release the business or the other guarantors.
And an offer doesn't stop collection. Treasury can still take your tax refund, and garnish up to fifteen percent of your pay, even in Texas.
So the question isn't just whether it can be settled. It's which path fits your loan.
Herrin Law has handled more than thirteen thousand cases. Call for a free consultation, and we'll map your options.
The good news is that federal law does allow SBA debt to be settled for less than the full balance in the right circumstances. The hard truth is that there is no single "SBA settlement program." The process that applies to you depends on four things: which loan program you have, who is collecting it right now, who signed for it, and what you actually need resolved. This guide walks through each one the way we do in a consultation, using the published rules rather than sales promises.
Can You Settle an SBA Loan for Less Than You Owe?
Yes, in some cases. Federal law gives SBA, and Treasury after referral, the power to compromise a debt for less than the balance, but no one is entitled to a settlement and no published percentage applies. SBA's authority comes from 15 U.S.C. § 634(b)(2). The Federal Claims Collection Standards at 31 CFR Part 902 list the grounds for a compromise:
- The debtor can't pay the full amount within a reasonable time.
- The government can't collect the full amount through enforcement.
- The cost of collecting would be out of proportion to the amount recovered.
- There's significant doubt that the government could prove its case.
An offer in compromise (often called an "OIC") is a written proposal to resolve a defined debt for less than what's owed. It's a negotiation backed by evidence. Reviewers compare what you are offering against what the government could realistically collect from you, your business, the collateral, and every guarantor. A strong hardship story without the documents to back it up is not an offer they can accept.
Is an SBA offer in compromise the same as an IRS offer in compromise?
No. The SBA and Treasury process is not an IRS offer in compromise, and the IRS formulas do not automatically apply. People who have been through an IRS OIC often expect the same expense standards and "reasonable collection potential" math. The published federal standards for nontax debt look at income, assets, age and health, exemptions, and collection costs, but they do not adopt the IRS formula. If you are dealing with tax debt instead, see our guide to the IRS offer in compromise in Texas.
Which SBA Loan Do You Have, and Why Does It Matter?
The loan program determines which rulebook applies, so it is the first thing to confirm. Here's how the main programs differ:
| Program | Governing procedure | What it means for settlement |
|---|---|---|
| 7(a) | SBA SOP 50 57 4 (effective Nov. 1, 2025), Chapter 21; 13 CFR Part 120 | Ordinarily expects the business to close and collateral to be liquidated first. A narrow "going concern" route exists for operating businesses. |
| 504 | SBA SOP 50 55, Chapter 23 | The CDC/SBA debt is separate from the bank's first-lien loan. Settling one does not settle the other. |
| Non-COVID disaster loan | SOP 50 52 2, Chapter 21, plus SBA's current OIC requirements letter | Liquidation of collateral normally comes before an offer; a viable-business exception is rare. |
| COVID EIDL | Current SBA COVID servicing rules, your loan documents, and federal collection law | SBA says COVID EIDL loans are not forgivable. Whether a compromise will be reviewed has to be confirmed account by account. |
Does my business have to close before I can make an offer?
Not always, but for most programs the ordinary path assumes closure, and keeping the business open requires meeting strict conditions. Under the current 7(a) manual, a compromise with a business that keeps operating requires, among other things, that the compromise be necessary to avoid closure, that other alternatives have been exhausted, that the restructuring involve all creditors under signed written agreements, and that SBA be treated fairly compared with those other creditors. A temporary cash-flow problem is not enough. The disaster manual treats a viable going concern as a rare exception.
What we tell clients: never close a viable business just to "qualify" for an offer. Closing a business does not release the note or your personal guaranty. Before anyone recommends a shutdown, compare the operating route, a workout, what happens to the collateral, and where you would stand afterward. Our article on whether closing your Texas business ends your personal liability for an EIDL loan covers that question in detail.
What is different about COVID EIDL loans?
COVID EIDL loans are the most uncertain category, and no published, generally available COVID EIDL offer-in-compromise program exists. Here is what SBA's published materials actually say:
- COVID EIDL loans cannot be forgiven.
- SBA has offered payment assistance to qualifying borrowers whose accounts are still with SBA. The current version reduces payments to 50% for six months, interest keeps running, and eligibility must be checked against SBA's live instructions. Payment assistance lowers payments for a while. It does not reduce what you owe.
- Personal guaranties were required on COVID EIDL loans over $200,000, and collateral on loans over $25,000. Your signed documents, including any loan increase, control your actual exposure.
- Treasury states that it cannot return COVID EIDL or PPP debts to SBA once they have been referred.
That last point answers a question we hear constantly: "Can I get my loan sent back to SBA?" For COVID EIDL, Treasury says no. Anyone selling a "return to SBA" strategy for a COVID EIDL account is selling something the published rules don't support.
The uncertainty cuts both ways. "Not forgivable" does not mean every individual compromise is legally prohibited, and general Treasury authority does not mean Treasury will settle every COVID EIDL account. For these loans, the first job is a written answer to one question: will this account be considered for a compromise, and who decides?
My SBA Loan Was Sent to Treasury. Is It Too Late to Settle?
No. Referral to Treasury does not by itself end the possibility of a compromise, but it changes who you negotiate with and who has to approve the deal. Once SBA refers a delinquent debt, it typically goes to the Treasury Bureau of the Fiscal Service's Cross-Servicing program, which may assign it to a private collection agency (PCA). The Treasury Financial Manual says Cross-Servicing generally holds the creditor agency's compromise authority, plus a delegation from the Department of Justice for debts with principal up to $500,000. Larger compromises generally require DOJ approval.
"At Treasury" can mean several different things, and they aren't interchangeable:
- Treasury Offset Program (TOP). Federal payments such as tax refunds are intercepted and applied to the debt.
- Cross-Servicing. Treasury is actively collecting on SBA's behalf.
- Private collection agency. A contractor collects for Treasury, usually with limited settlement authority.
- DOJ or a lawsuit. Government lawyers are involved, and court deadlines apply.
Why does the collection agency say it can't settle?
A private collection agency often doesn't have the final say, so "we don't settle these" may describe its own limits rather than the law. Treasury describes its contractors as operating with limited settlement authority. When a collector refuses, the useful follow-up questions are:
- Is the restriction specific to this loan program, this account, or this contractor's authority?
- Is the problem that you offered too little, or that no offer will be reviewed at all?
- Can the proposal be sent to Treasury, SBA, or DOJ for a decision outside the collector's authority?
- What written policy supports the restriction?
Write down who said what and when. A collector telling you "you can send something" means you can submit an offer. It doesn't mean the offer will be approved.
Can the Treasury Collection Fee Be Removed?
Sometimes, but not automatically. A fee that was calculated wrong can be corrected, and a valid fee can be waived or folded into an all-in settlement. Federal law authorizes Treasury to add collection costs to referred debts (31 U.S.C. § 3711(g)(6) and 31 CFR § 285.12(j)), and 31 CFR § 901.9 governs interest, penalties, administrative costs, and waivers. The rules do not set one fee percentage for every SBA debt, so start by asking for an itemized balance as of a specific date that breaks out:
- Unpaid principal, with every payment and collateral credit.
- Contract interest, and the rate and dates used.
- Any statutory interest or penalties, and the authority for them.
- Treasury collection costs, including the formula and the balance they were calculated on.
- Every offset taken (tax refunds and other federal payments) and how it was applied.
Then keep three requests separate: a correction (a specific error, with proof), a waiver (the authority and why its standard is met), and an all-in compromise (one total payment that expressly resolves principal, interest, penalties, and fees). A settlement that resolves only "principal" can leave the collection fee still collectible. The agreement should state the total you will pay and exactly what that payment resolves.
What If I Personally Guaranteed the Loan?
Each borrower and each guarantor is a separate obligor. Settling one person's liability does not automatically release anyone else. The federal compromise standards preserve the government's claims against people who aren't part of a settlement (31 CFR § 902.4). In practice:
- A global settlement covering the business and all guarantors usually requires a business financial package plus a separate personal financial package for each guarantor. One business and two guarantors means three separate packages.
- An individual settlement for one guarantor is a different request. It can leave the business and the other guarantors fully liable.
- Your ownership percentage is not the limit of your liability. If you signed an unlimited guaranty, the government can pursue you for the full balance whether you owned 10% or 90% of the company.
- A spouse's information may be requested on the financial forms. Providing it does not make your spouse a guarantor. What your spouse signed controls.
If a business partner won't cooperate, a global deal may not be practical, but your own individual release may still be worth pursuing. For more on how guaranties play out, see SBA loan default and bankruptcy options for Texas business owners.
What if I have assets the government could collect from?
Owning real assets doesn't rule out a compromise, but it changes what a realistic offer looks like, because the offer is measured against what the government could actually collect from you. Investment accounts, cryptocurrency, cash, and real estate that isn't your homestead all count toward that estimate. A guarantor with substantial reachable assets should expect any reduction to reflect mainly the time, cost, and risk the government would face in collecting, not an inability to pay.
That leaves a guarantor in this position with a few realistic paths:
- A lump-sum compromise funded by an asset. SBA prefers cash, normally within 60 days of approval. Selling part of an investment position to fund a lump sum can be worth comparing against paying the full balance over time.
- A repayment arrangement before referral. While the loan is still with the lender or SBA, a workout or repayment agreement may be available. It usually doesn't reduce principal, and interest keeps running at the note rate, but it can keep the account from being referred to Treasury.
- Bankruptcy, with eyes open. For an individual guarantor with significant non-exempt assets, Chapter 7 would generally put those assets in front of a trustee, so it is rarely the better tool. Chapter 13 can restructure payments over three to five years, but unsecured creditors must receive at least what they would get in a Chapter 7, which again reflects your assets.
Timing matters most before referral. Once a debt goes to Treasury Cross-Servicing, collection costs can be added and the people with authority to approve a settlement change (see My SBA Loan Was Sent to Treasury). If a demand letter gives a deadline, the decision about which path to take should be made before it passes.
Because an offer requires complete financial disclosure on SBA Form 770, signed under penalty of law, it makes sense to evaluate whether an offer is likely to succeed before submitting one. That evaluation is a decision about whether to make an offer. It is never a reason to leave an asset off the forms if you do.
What Documents Does an SBA Offer in Compromise Require?
Expect SBA Form 1150 (the offer), SBA Form 770 (personal financial statement) for each individual, two years of tax returns, and recent bank and income records, plus Treasury's own forms if the debt has been referred. SBA's current disaster-loan OIC requirements letter (revised July 10, 2026) asks for:
- A signed offer and hardship explanation, with SBA Form 1150 and SBA Form 770.
- A representative authorization if an attorney is involved.
- The most recent two years of tax returns.
- Two months of income evidence.
- Six months of bank and investment statements.
- Current business financial statements and a business debt schedule.
- Evidence of closure, if the business has closed, plus valuation and title records for any lien-release request.
That letter asks for a response within 30 calendar days and describes reviewing a complete package within 15 business days. That's a completeness review, not a promise of a decision or a pause in collection. For 7(a) and 504 loans, the lender or CDC usually prepares SBA's "OIC Tabs" package. At Treasury, expect the Fiscal Service consumer and commercial financial statements, which are separate from the SBA forms.
Do I have to disclose my IRA, house, and other assets?
Yes. Disclose every asset, including retirement accounts and property you believe is exempt, and keep the question of whether it can be collected separate from the disclosure. The forms are signed under penalty of law. SBA Form 770 asks about transfers of $500 or more during the prior three years, and Form 1150 asks about property transferred since the debt arose. Whether a retirement account or your Texas homestead can actually be reached is a legal question your attorney argues in the offer. Leaving an asset off the form is not a strategy. An omitted asset can sink the offer and create a far bigger problem than the debt.
The same goes for moving assets. Don't retitle property, form a new company, or shift money around to look poorer before an offer. Reviewers look for exactly that, and the forms ask about it directly.
How Is a Fair Settlement Amount Determined?
The offer has to make sense compared with what the government could realistically collect, and no standard discount or "cents on the dollar" figure applies to SBA debt. Be skeptical of anyone who quotes a percentage before seeing your file. A well-built offer estimates the government's realistic recovery:
realizable value of the collateral + other assets the government can legally reach + realistic future collections from each obligor − the cost of collecting, adjusted for time and legal risk
Then it shows where the settlement money will come from. A credible offer usually has a real funding source, such as a lump sum from family, the sale of an asset, or a documented third-party commitment. Under the 7(a) manual, SBA prefers cash, normally paid within 60 days after approval. Installment compromises are generally limited to three years, and SBA's 7(a) manual generally sets a $5,000 minimum, which can be lowered for hardship. That minimum is a floor, not a target.
Watch for double counting. The same collateral shouldn't be counted once as a business asset and again as a guarantor's asset, and a jointly owned home shouldn't be counted as a full asset of both spouses. Getting this math right is often where an offer is won or lost.
Does Submitting an Offer Stop Collection?
No. An offer in compromise does not automatically stop Treasury offsets, wage garnishment, or a lawsuit. Any pause has to be requested separately and confirmed in writing. Wage garnishment is the deadline that catches Texans off guard. Texas law protects wages from garnishment for most consumer debts, but federal administrative wage garnishment (31 CFR § 285.11) applies regardless of state law:
- You must receive written notice at least 30 days before garnishment begins.
- If your hearing request is received by the 15th business day after the notice was mailed, no withholding order should issue until the hearing is decided.
- A later request still gets a hearing, but without that automatic protection.
- Withholding is generally limited to 15% of disposable pay, and you can ask for a hardship review.
Calendar every deadline on every notice. A settlement conversation is not an extension of time to answer a federal lawsuit. And don't stop paying on purpose to create "leverage." Deliberate default adds interest and fees, invites referral, and doesn't make an offer more likely to succeed.
What Happens If the Offer Is Rejected or Accepted?
A rejection is not always final, and an acceptance is not finished until the release is in writing and the terms are performed. Find out what kind of rejection you received: an incomplete package, the wrong office, a contractor without authority, an amount the reviewer thinks is too low, or a final decision on the merits. Each one leads to a different next step. There is no uniform appeal process for every SBA or Treasury compromise denial, so read the decision itself and ask what review, if any, is available.
If the offer is accepted, read the agreement before any money moves. It should name every settling party, every loan number, and how principal, interest, penalties, and collection fees are treated. It should also say when the release takes effect and what happens to liens and pending garnishments or offsets. In an installment compromise, default can restore the original balance minus your payments (31 CFR § 902.2(f)), so the payment plan has to be one you can actually keep.
Will I owe taxes on a settled SBA loan?
Possibly. Forgiven debt can count as taxable income, though exclusions such as insolvency and bankruptcy may apply. You may receive a Form 1099-C for the forgiven amount. IRS Publication 4681 explains the insolvency and bankruptcy exclusions, and excluded debt can reduce other tax benefits. Talk to your tax preparer before you sign so the settlement makes sense after taxes. Being unable to pay the SBA does not automatically mean you meet the tax definition of insolvency.
When Is Bankruptcy Better Than an SBA Settlement?
Bankruptcy can be the better path when there is no money to fund an offer, when several guarantors or creditors are involved, or when collection is moving faster than a negotiation can. SBA debt is generally dischargeable in bankruptcy like other unsecured business debt, and the automatic stay stops collection right away. (If you are already in bankruptcy, an offer needs court permission.) Chapter 7 can discharge a guarantor's personal liability. Chapter 11 Subchapter V or Chapter 13 can let an operating business or an individual restructure on a plan. See can SBA loans be discharged in bankruptcy in Texas and our page on Chapter 11 Subchapter V for Texas small businesses.
Other options worth comparing include:
| Option | When it fits | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Servicing workout or deferment | Temporary hardship, loan still with the lender or SBA | Usually doesn't reduce principal |
| COVID EIDL payment assistance | Qualifying account still at SBA | Lowers payments only, and isn't assumed available after Treasury referral |
| Installment agreement | You can pay in full over time | It's a repayment plan, not a compromise |
| Balance or fee correction | Missing credits, wrong interest, duplicated fees | Reduces the balance but doesn't release the debt |
| Liability dispute | Wrong person, limited or missing guaranty, prior release | Depends on the signed documents |
| Bankruptcy | No funding source, multiple debts, active collection | Requires a separate eligibility analysis |
How Herrin Law Approaches SBA Debt
We first verify your SBA loan details and who is currently collecting, then quickly assess whether relief options like an Offer in Compromise—sometimes settling for as little as 20%—are realistic for your situation. With over 13,000 cases handled, we tell you upfront if a settlement or bankruptcy is your best path.
We start with a defined review, not a promise. Before anyone prepares a full offer package, we confirm the loan program, who is collecting now, who signed what, the deadlines in play, and whether an office will actually consider the relief you need. If an offer isn't the right fit, you'll hear that early, along with the option that is. With more than 13,000 cases filed and a practice built around Texas business owners with SBA, EIDL, and merchant cash advance debt, we've seen how these accounts move from the lender to SBA to Treasury.
If you have an SBA or Treasury demand letter, gather the latest notice (all pages and the envelope), your note and any guaranty you signed, and your recent payment history. Then call (469) 607-8552 for a free consultation, or learn more on our SBA loan default page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an SBA loan be settled for less than the balance?
Yes, in some cases. SBA, and Treasury after referral, can compromise a debt when the debtor can't pay in full within a reasonable time, enforced collection wouldn't recover the full amount, collection costs are out of proportion, or the government's case is doubtful (31 CFR § 902.2). No one is entitled to a settlement, and no standard percentage applies.
Can a COVID EIDL loan be settled or forgiven?
SBA states that COVID EIDL loans are not forgivable, and no published, generally available COVID EIDL offer-in-compromise program exists. Whether a compromise will be reviewed has to be confirmed in writing for your specific account. SBA payment assistance can temporarily lower payments for qualifying accounts still at SBA, but it does not reduce the balance.
Will SBA take my loan back from Treasury?
For COVID EIDL and PPP debts, Treasury states that it cannot return them to SBA. Other referred debts can be recalled in limited situations, such as a debt that was invalid or improperly referred, but asking for a return just to regain SBA's servicing options is not an established path.
Do I need to submit financial statements for every guarantor?
For a global settlement that releases the business and every guarantor, expect a business package plus a separate personal package for each guarantor. If you are seeking a release for only yourself, the request is narrower, but it can leave the business and the other guarantors liable.
Does an offer in compromise stop wage garnishment?
No. A pending offer doesn't automatically stop administrative wage garnishment, Treasury offsets, or a lawsuit. To protect your wages, request a hearing so it is received by the 15th business day after the garnishment notice was mailed, and ask in writing for any collection hold you need.
Is the Treasury collection fee negotiable?
It can be corrected if it was calculated wrong, waived if the waiver standard is met, or resolved as part of an all-in settlement. Ask for an itemized balance first, and make sure any settlement states the total payment and that it covers principal, interest, penalties, and collection costs.
Should I close my business to qualify for an SBA settlement?
Not without analysis. Closing doesn't release the note or your guaranty, and some programs allow a compromise with an operating business under strict conditions. Compare the operating route, a workout, and bankruptcy before shutting down a viable business.
Can I settle an SBA loan if I have investments or other assets?
Possibly, but expect a smaller reduction. The offer is compared with what the government could collect, and reachable assets such as brokerage accounts, cryptocurrency, and non-homestead real estate raise that number. A lump sum paid within about 60 days, often funded by selling part of an asset, is the most common structure.
Term: Offer in compromise (OIC): A written proposal to resolve a defined federal debt for less than the full balance, approved only by an office with authority to accept it.
Term: Cross-Servicing: The Treasury Bureau of the Fiscal Service program that collects delinquent federal nontax debts referred by agencies like SBA.
Term: Administrative wage garnishment (AWG): A federal process that lets the government withhold up to 15% of disposable pay without a court judgment, after notice and a chance for a hearing.
Sources
- 15 U.S.C. § 634(b)(2); 31 U.S.C. § 3711
- 13 CFR § 120.536; 31 CFR Parts 900–903; 31 CFR §§ 285.11, 285.12
- SBA SOP 50 57 4 (7(a) servicing, effective Nov. 1, 2025); SOP 50 55 (504); SOP 50 52 2 (disaster)
- SBA Offer in Compromise Requirements letter (rev. July 10, 2026); SBA Forms 1150 and 770
- Treasury Financial Manual Vol. I, Part 3, Ch. 5000 (Cross-Servicing); Bureau of the Fiscal Service debtor guidance
- IRS Topic No. 431 and Publication 4681 (canceled debt)
Note: This article reflects federal rules and agency guidance as of October 2026. SBA and Treasury procedures change often, so confirm current requirements for your account.